An analysis of hospital administrative costs across 8 countries found hospital bureaucracy accounts for a quarter of hospital spending in the United States.
An analysis of hospital administrative costs across 8 countries found hospital bureaucracy accounts for a quarter of hospital spending in the United States, according to a study in Health Affairs.
The international research team led by David Himmelstein, MD, used data from 2010 or 2011 to compare hospital administration costs in the US with Canada, England, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Scotland, and Wales. Administrative costs in the US were by far the highest (25.3%), followed by the Netherlands (19.8%), and England (15.5%). In Scotland and Canada, both single-payer systems, administrative costs were only about 12%.
According to the researchers, reducing US per capita spending for hospital administration to the level of Scotland of Canada would have saved more than $150 billion in 2011.
“We’re squandering $150 billion each year on hospital bureaucracy,” Himmelstein, a professor at the City University of New York’s (CUNY) Hunter College School of Public Health and lecturer at Harvard Medical School, said in a statement. “And $300 billion more is wasted each year on insurance companies’ overhead and the paperwork they inflict on doctors.”
In the US, for-profit hospitals spend a larger portion of costs on administration (27%) compared with nonprofits (25%), public (23%), and teaching (24%) hospitals. From 2000 to 2011 hospital administrative costs increased 120% from $97.8 billion to $215.4 billion.
Since the Netherlands and England are both transitioning to market-oriented payment systems, the authors write that the data suggests a simpler and less market-oriented payment scheme would reduce administrative costs.
“Only a single-payer reform can squeeze out the bureaucratic waste and use the money to give patients the care they need,” Himmelstein said. “Instead, we’re layering on more bureaucracy in insurance exchanges and accountable care organizations.”
While the proportion of hospital costs spent on administration rose in the US from 23.5% in 2000 to 25.3% in 2011, Canada’s costs decreased from 12.9% to 12.4% during that same time period.
Unfortunately, the study reported there was no evidence that America’s higher administrative costs translated to better quality care or yielded any other benefits.
“For 3 decades our policy makers have pushed market-oriented strategies that have turned health care into a business,” Steffie Woolhandler, MD, MPH, senior author and a professor at CUNY’s Hunter College, said in a statement. “As a result, Americans now have the world’s costliest health care, and our life expectancy is years shorter than in most other wealthy nations. It’s time to admit that, when it comes to caring for sick people, markets don’t work.”
Overcoming Employment Barriers for Lasting Social Impact: Freedom House 2.0 and Pathways to Work
April 16th 2024To help celebrate and recognize National Minority Health Month, we are bringing you a special month-long podcast series with our Strategic Alliance Partner, UPMC Health Plan. Welcome to our second episode, in which we learn all about Freedom House 2.0 and the Pathways to Work program.
Listen
Pegcetacoplan for PNH More Cost-Effective Than Anti-C5 Monoclonal Antibodies
April 18th 2024A cost-utility analysis conducted from the perspective of the Italian health system found that pegcetacoplan was more effective and less costly than 2 complement 5 (C5) inhibitors for the treatment of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH).
Read More
Making Giant Strides in Maternity Health Through Baby Steps
April 9th 2024To help celebrate and recognize National Minority Health Month, we are kicking off a special month-long podcast series with our strategic alliance partner, UPMC Health Plan. Welcome to our first episode, which is all about the Baby Steps Maternity Program and its mission to support women throughout every step of their pregnancy journey.
Listen
Collecting SDOH Data Can Assess Risk of Medical Nonadherence, Improve HEI and Star Ratings
April 18th 2024At the Academy of Managed Care Pharmacy (AMCP) 2024 annual meeting, a panel of presenters explored changes coming to Medicare that incorporate social determinants of health (SDOH) data to improve patient and health system outcomes.
Read More
Many Patients With Psoriasis in Clinical Trials Experience Nocebo Effects, Study Finds
April 18th 2024Half of patients exposed to placebo in clinical trials experienced adverse events (AEs), which may be partially explainable by nocebo effects, according to a recent review and meta-analysis.
Read More