Incentives in employee wellness programs, especially penalties, can hurt morale and lead to legal action. But without incentives, there's no guarantee the employer will see healthcare savings and return on investment.
From the trends in corporate wellness spending, to the announcement that the life insurer John Hancock will offer discounts for health data, the quest to get Americans to eat better and exercise has revealed a few things: offering rewards may work, but penalties will cause trouble.
The federal government is at odds with itself when it comes to whether employers have the right to require wellness among employees. The Affordable Care Act allows employers to connect up to 30% of health plan premium to wellness initiatives, and the CDC has just unveiled a major effort to find people with prediabetes and intervene before it progresses.
At the same time, another agency—the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission—has sued 3 companies over the design of their corporate wellness programs, saying they violated anti-discrimination laws by coercing employees to take part.
It’s all about the difference between penalties and incentives. Rewards can include gift cards, premium discounts, or contributions to a health spending account.
A survey by Fidelity Investments and the National Business Group on Health found that 80% of employers are offering health improvement programs at an average cost of $693 per worker, with large companies spending even more. However, while typical features include incentives for physical activity programs (54%) or biometic screenings (72%), only 6% use disincentives for not taking a health assessment, down from 11% in 2014.
The Health Enhancement Research Organization found that tying financial incentives, especially penalties, to participation in a corporate wellness program can affect employee morale, invite legal challenges, and harm a company’s reputation—when “wellness” should be a feel-good word that invites positive feedback. However, offering programs without incentives makes them options that employees can take or leave. Then, the programs don’t necessarily lead to lower healthcare costs to the employer, which is the return on investment that makes them worthwhile in the first place.
Who takes part in such programs? The Fidelity survey found less than half of employees used them to their full extent, earning all incentives, while 26% earned some incentives.
There must be a market for some Americans willing leverage their healthy behavior for financial gain: on Wednesday, John Hancock announced it would partner with the global wellness company Vitality to tie discounts to life insurance products for customers willing to wear a Fitbit and share information about workouts, physical exams, and even their mood.
The question is whether efforts like these will go beyond those who are relatively healthy, or bring real behavioral change to the less healthy Americans who account for most healthcare spending.
Around the Web
Employer wellness programs spend record $693 per worker
Reducing Low-Value Care Is Hard, but What About Just Not Paying for It?
March 14th 2024After years of efforts to reduce low-value care, panelists at the 2024 Value-Based Insurance Design Summit proposed a new strategy: drawing a line in the sand that payers will not be on the hook for these services.
Read More
How Can Employers Leverage the DPP to Improve Diabetes Rates?
February 15th 2022On this episode of Managed Care Cast, Jill Hutt, vice president of member services at the Greater Philadelphia Business Coalition on Health, explains the Coalition’s efforts to reduce diabetes rates through the Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP).
Listen
Key Issues Influencing 2022 Employer Health Care Strategy and Plan Design
August 31st 2021On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we speak with Ellen Kelsay, president and CEO of the Business Group on Health, on the findings from her organization's 2022 Large Employers’ Health Care Strategy and Plan Design Survey.
Listen
Retaining Health Care Workers Starts With Insights on “How We Can Stop Breaking Them”
March 2nd 2024Friday's keynote speaker, Katherine A. Meese, PhD, addressed the conference theme of workforce support at the Association of Cancer Care Centers 50th Annual Meeting and Cancer Center Business Summit.
Read More