Currently Viewing:
V-BID Summit

The Challenge of Addressing Low-Value Care Once It's Identified

Laura Joszt
Panelists discussed low-value care, unnecessary services, and what can be done to address overuse in healthcare during a panel at the University of Michigan Center for Value-Based Insurance Design’s (V-BID) annual V-BID Summit on March 14.
 
Identifying low-value care can save a state hundreds of millions of dollars in just 1 year, found Beth Bortz, president and CEO of the Virginia Center for Health Innovation (VCHI). She and her fellow panelists, Lauren Vela, MBA, senior director of the Pacific Business Group on Health, and Daniel Wolfson, executive vice president and chief operating officer of the ABIM Foundation, discussed low-value care, unnecessary services, and what can be done to address overuse in healthcare during a panel at the University of Michigan Center for Value-Based Insurance Design’s (V-BID) annual V-BID Summit on March 14.

VCHI was trying to let CMS know that it could lower the cost of care and in the course of trying to understand how much low-value care was happening in Virginia and what could be done about it, VCHI came across ABIM Foundation’s Choosing Wisely initiative.

“We very much wanted our physician community in Virginia to be on board, and we thought the best place to start was with services that the physicians, themselves, identified and said, ‘These are tests and procedures that we routinely do that we know to be unnecessary and potentially harmful,’” Bortz explained. “So that was a great starting point for us.”

The point is not to look at simply if a test or procedure is done in a vacuum, because what could be a low-value service for many might be a high-value service for someone else, depending on what other factors and risks are taken into consideration.

Wolfson added that the Choosing Wisely campaign defines overuse as when the risks outweigh the benefits with the support of evidence. The campaign doesn’t even define low-value care, he explained. The campaign is clinically nuanced.

“It’s not an absolute,” he said. “There are times when the red flags would necessitate a test that is generally recommended not to be used.”

Clinical evidence is an important part of this process. With so many things that need to be paid for in healthcare, Vela said it would be a sham to pay for something that clinical evidence says does not need to be done. She said that identifying and addressing low-value care “looms as a very large opportunity.” The challenge is translating a conversation around low-value care into something that is action-oriented for employers.

The fact that the Choosing Wisely campaign and the actions of VCHI were never supposed to just be to reduce costs is also an important message to get out. Wolfson explained that the purpose of Choosing Wisely was to enhance safety, quality, and affordability—some of the recommendations actually increase costs. He provided the example of tube feeding versus manual feeding in nursing homes. While tube feeding is less costly, it kills people over time; but manually feeding a patient costs more money, so it was less popular.

“We wanted to take a baby step,” Wolfson said. “And a baby step was just looking at low-hanging fruit. Cost effectiveness is a more difficult, nuanced thing to be able to look at. We wanted to be able to get people in the game first and then think about cost effectiveness.”

In Virginia, Bortz’s organization looked at 42 measures out of approximately 500 and the claims data on 5 million Virginians and found that more than $700 million a year was spent on unnecessary care, as defined by the Choosing Wisely program and those services that received a D grade from the United States Preventive Services Task Force.

VCHI took this report out into the field to show to employers and providers. Bortz made the mistake of leading with the top 5 services by cost and “got schooled pretty quickly.” Physicians didn’t want to hear the word “waste” in these discussions and they wanted to see a low-value index, which should what services are they doing wrong all the time. Employers didn’t want their employees to feel like “this was all about a money grab.” They wanted to see the top 5 list by harm.



Related Articles

Physician Perceptions of Choosing Wisely and Drivers of Overuse
Choosing Wisely Brings Lots of Energy, but No Growth in Awareness
Five Years of Reducing Overuse of Medical Services With Choosing Wisely
Low-Value Services Accounted for $282 Million of Healthcare Spending in Washington State
Dr Robert Dubois Explains Challenges in Addressing Low-Value Services
 
Copyright AJMC 2006-2018 Clinical Care Targeted Communications Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
x
Welcome the the new and improved AJMC.com, the premier managed market network. Tell us about yourself so that we can serve you better.
Sign Up
×

Sign In

Not a member? Sign up now!