The recent dispute over the accuracy of the cardiovascular risk calculator points up the power and limitations of "big data," as well as the need for a blueprint for health guidelines aimed at consumers.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE JANUARY 20, 2014
What’s Behind the CV Risk Calculator Controversy?
PLAINSBORO, N.J. — November’s dispute over the accuracy of the cardiovascular risk calculator, unveiled with great fanfare at the annual meeting of the American Heart Association, highlights both the power and limitations of “big data” in healthcare, according to a story published this month in Evidence-Based Diabetes Management, a publication of The American Journal of Managed Care.
The CV risk calculator, developed by a joint committee of the American College of Cardiology and the American Heart Association, has generally received good reviews for its emphasis on preventing stroke and heart disease. But the points of contention were serious enough that the uproar landed on the front page of The New York Times just as the new guidelines were being launched.
What’s at issue? Critics of the calculator say it vastly overestimates the number of people who should be taking statins, in large measure because the tool relies too heavily on a person’s age. Evidence-Based Diabetes Management explores how the use of different data sets by the calculator’s creators and a pair of Harvard researchers who questioned its accuracy fueled the controversy. Defenders say critics are relying on news reports, not the guidelines themselves. For the full story, click here.
Questions about the risk calculator and other aspects of the guidelines have sparked a separate debate, one that concerns how guidelines designed for widespread consumer use are created in the first place. Some observers of the flap over the ACC/AHA guidelines told EBDM that the mere existence of the dispute shows that the committee failed to take sufficient steps to ensure widespread acceptance.
“Every time a controversy plays out like this, it hurts patients. Many people will leap from the assertion that this calculator recommends statins too frequently to the conclusion that they should always refuse to use statins,” Steven Nissen, MD, of the Cleveland Clinic told EBDM.
The lack of an accepted blueprint for developing consumer health guidelines is part of the problem. A member of the ACC/AHA guidelines committee said that Institute of Medicine is trying to address that issue. “They were talking about guideline writing committees that had designed good processes,” said David Lloyd-Jones, MD, ScM, of Northwestern University.
CONTACT: Mary Caffrey (609) 716-7777 x. 144
mcaffrey@ajmc.com , www.ajmc.com Follow us on @EBDiabetes
For National Women’s Health Week, One Company Emphasizes Cardiovascular Risk Management
May 10th 2022On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we speak with Joanne Armstrong, MD, MPH, vice president and chief medical officer for Women’s Health and Genomics at CVS Health, on the distinct pathophysiology of cardiovascular disease in women and how her own health experiences have influenced her perspective on cardiovascular disease management.
Listen
How Can Employers Leverage the DPP to Improve Diabetes Rates?
February 15th 2022On this episode of Managed Care Cast, Jill Hutt, vice president of member services at the Greater Philadelphia Business Coalition on Health, explains the Coalition’s efforts to reduce diabetes rates through the Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP).
Listen
Interactive mHealth App Helped Improve Patients’ Lifestyle Habits After Undergoing PCI
April 29th 2024These lifestyle improvements included adherence to the Mediterranean diet, improved frequency of healthy food consumption, increased physical activity, and quitting smoking, among other factors.
Read More
HOPE-CAT Can Identify Maternal Cardiovascular Risk 2 Months Earlier Than Doctors, Study Says
April 25th 2024In a retrospective study, the machine learning tool was able to screen for potential risks of cardiovascular disease nearly 60 days before the patient's medical record showed any signs of a related condition or before they were officially diagnosed or treated for it.
Read More