Many value assessment frameworks are still in their infancy and while the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO)'s framework is still getting input and being adjusted, it has started an important conversation, Stephen Grubbs, MD, vice president for clinical affairs at ASCO, said at the Community Oncology Alliance's 2016 Community Oncology Conference.
Many value assessment frameworks are still in their infancy and while the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO)'s framework is still getting input and being adjusted, it has started an important conversation, Stephen Grubbs, MD, vice president for clinical affairs at ASCO, said at the Community Oncology Alliance's 2016 Community Oncology Conference.
Transcript (slightly modified)
What distinguishes the ASCO Value Framework from the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN)'s Evidence Blocks and the Institute for Clinical and Economic Review's Value Assessment Framework?
Right now, I think, we are all beginning to try to figure out what is the definition of value? And of course it depends on who is looking at it. The perspective I think we've had at ASCO, and really at NCCN, is looking at saying the value needs to be given to the patient for them to make a better-informed decision. So I think both of us have worked pretty much in similar ways, even though they're a little bit different, in trying to come up with some way of translating the benefits and risks of a treatment and it's cost to a patient at any point in time so they can begin to weigh out all of these factors in trying to make a better informed decision.
So I think NCCN and ASCO have a little different methodology to come up with, I think, a similar type of product to offer patients and their physicians to have that discussion. I can give the details of the ASCO program, and where we are with that is really the first attempt to try and define value for a patient to use. And it really needs to be adjusted and developed over time. So ASCO had a large commitee of our members, volunteers, and others put together a first shot at a value framework that was published last year in the Journal of Clinical Oncology.
Basically the framework works where one looks at the evidence of the benefit of the treatment—and the benefit will be defined as a high cure rate, a longer time in control of the disease, a longer survivorship—and along with that it measures against that the toxicity—and the toxicity meaning how the drug has negative effects on the patient. And what they've come up with is a numerical system to begin to develop a "net health benefit." The pluses are the benefits you get from treatment; the minuses the toxicities you pay. And once that net health benefit between 2 different treatments is calculated, then you begin to look at the cost differential between the 2 treatments.
This is really just started and it's not ready for primetime use and it has to have a lot of adjustments, it has to be developed even more, but it's started the conversation. There's input being put into it, and it's actually being adjusted as we speak and sometime this year it will be republished in a new form. But it's certainly on its way.
ATS 2024: Bridging the Past, Present, and Future of Respiratory Care
May 16th 2024The application of artificial intelligence in medicine is anticipated as a highlight of ATS 2024, with sessions exploring its applications in research, radiological interpretation, and pediatric pulmonology.
Read More
Examining Low-Value Cancer Care Trends Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic
April 25th 2024On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we're talking with the authors of a study published in the April 2024 issue of The American Journal of Managed Care® about their findings on the rates of low-value cancer care services throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.
Listen
Oncology Onward: A Conversation With Penn Medicine's Dr Justin Bekelman
December 19th 2023Justin Bekelman, MD, director of the Penn Center for Cancer Care Innovation, sat with our hosts Emeline Aviki, MD, MBA, and Stephen Schleicher, MD, MBA, for our final episode of 2023 to discuss the importance of collaboration between academic medicine and community oncology and testing innovative cancer care delivery in these settings.
Listen
Posters Characterize DMD Caregiver Experiences, Impact of Gene Therapy on Caregiving Demands
May 10th 2024Posters presented at the ISPOR—The Professional Society for Health Economics and Outcomes Research meeting explored Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) caregiver experiences and gene therapy’s impact on work opportunities for caregivers.
Read More