CMS' star ratings for hospitals have been controversial because they penalize hospitals that disproportionately care for the poor and the sick, and efforts by CMS to adjust the methodology haven't really addressed the concerns, explained Ashish K. Jha, MD, MPH, the K.T. Li Professor of Health Policy at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and the director of the Harvard Global Health Institute.
CMS' star ratings for hospitals have been controversial because they penalize hospitals that disproportionately care for the poor and the sick, and efforts by CMS to adjust the methodology haven't really addressed the concerns, explained Ashish K. Jha, MD, MPH, the K.T. Li Professor of Health Policy at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and the director of the Harvard Global Health Institute.
Transcript (slightly modified)
There have been concerns over the Medicare stars program for hospitals. What are the issues people have regarding the penalties safety net and teaching hospitals are facing?
The hospital star ratings are relatively new and the concerns that people have outlined behind them are sort of several. One, there's a big picture question of, can you even take a hospital, which is a big complicated place, and give a single star rating that really captures the quality of care in that place? There's sort of a philosophical question of "is it even doable to give a single rating that really captures how good an institution is?"
The second, which is a more specific set of concerns, is when you look at the star ratings, when you look at the underlying methodology, what becomes really clear is that hospitals that disproportionately care for sick patients, hospitals that disproportionately care for poor patients are going to be far more likely to be penalized. And actually there are some reasons to believe that hospitals that are good, that are vigilant, that look for errors, that look for adverse events that might happen, are also much more likely to end up getting a bad rating.
And so the concerns are methodologic, really saying, "Look, we don't want to be calling the best hospitals—the ones that take care of the hardest patients, the sickest patients, the poorest patients—we don't want to be calling them 1, 2, or 3 stars when they're really some of the best hospitals in America."
CMS did make some changes to the methodology of the Medicare stars program for hospitals before releasing the ratings. What was the purpose of those changes and do you think they were enough to make a real impact on the final rating of a hospital?
So when CMS initially put out that it was going to have these star ratings, there was a lot of pushback. Individual hospitals got to look at their own star ratings and it appeared that some of the best hospitals in America were going to be rated poorly. So I think there was pushback on that. So CMS went back—the Yale Group that developed this measure went back and re-ran some analyses.
Does it fundamentally address the concerns that hospitals and others have raised? No, it doesn't. There were issues around giving poor scores to organizations that disproportionately care for the poor, disproportionately care for sick patients. Those issues are still in play. The effort was just trying to make it a little bit better, so that the program has a little more validity.
Dr Dalia Rotstein: Physicians Must Be Aware MS Affects People of All Backgrounds
April 24th 2024Dalia Rotstein, MD, MPH, emphazises the importance of awareness that multiple sclerosis (MS) impacts patients from various backgrounds as clinicians think through ways to improve access to care and research efforts in MS.
Read More
Empowering Community Health Through Wellness and Faith
April 23rd 2024To help celebrate and recognize National Minority Health Month, we are bringing you a special month-long podcast series with our Strategic Alliance Partner, UPMC Health Plan. In the third episode, Camille Clarke-Smith, EdD, MS, CHES, CPT, discusses approaching community health holistically through spiritual and community engagement.
Listen
Prices for care at hospital trauma centers vary across hospitals; drug shortages reached a record high during the first quarter of 2024; although 3 of the biggest makers of asthma inhalers pledged to cap out-of-pocket costs for some US patients at $35, these do not apply to daily inhalers used by the youngest kids with asthma.
Read More
Overcoming Employment Barriers for Lasting Social Impact: Freedom House 2.0 and Pathways to Work
April 16th 2024To help celebrate and recognize National Minority Health Month, we are bringing you a special month-long podcast series with our Strategic Alliance Partner, UPMC Health Plan. Welcome to our second episode, in which we learn all about Freedom House 2.0 and the Pathways to Work program.
Listen
Beyond Insulin: The Impact of Next-Generation Diabetes Technology
April 17th 2024Experts explain how new diabetes technologies like continuous glucose monitors are transforming care beyond intensive insulin therapy, offering personalized insights and improving outcomes for patients of all treatment levels.
Read More
The Biden administration recently launched the Global Health Security Strategy, a new effort to combat the spread of infectious diseases; lawmakers zeroed in on the risks of massive consolidation in health care during the first congressional hearing on the Change Healthcare hack; the FDA recently announced the recall of a pair of heart devices linked to numerous deaths and injuries.
Read More