Providing an in-person patient navigator to address family social needs can decrease child health care utilization, according to a study published in JAMA Network Open.
Previous research has established an association between social risk factors and child health outcomes, while professional medical organizations have endorsed screening for such factors in clinical settings.
Although uptake of screening has been inconsistent, the practice is more likely to occur in settings with high numbers of low-income patients. However, few studies have documented health effects of interventions designed to reduce identified social needs, according to researchers.
In a randomized clinical trial of 1300 families, investigators compared acute care utilization effects of a written resources handout with an in-person navigation service intervention to address social needs.
Between 2013 and 2015, adult caregivers of pediatric patients seen in primary and urgent care clinics of 2 safety-net hospitals in California were recruited to participate in the study. To address each family’s social needs, families were randomly assigned to an in-person navigator intervention (637 families [49%]) or an active control (663 families [51%]).
In the active control cohort, caregivers received written information about relevant local resources related to social needs, while the navigator intervention consisted of meeting with a patient navigator focused on helping resolve such social needs.
Specifically, “navigators contacted families every 2 weeks via telephone, email, or in person for up to 3 months or until either identified needs were met or caregivers declined ongoing assistance.” In the intervention group, navigators also “provided assistance connecting caregivers with clinic, government, or community resources targeted specifically to the social barriers that had been endorsed and prioritized by the caregiver.”
Social risk data were collected from each household using a questionnaire that asked about the following domains: food insecurity, problems paying utility bills, problems finding employment, housing instability, living in an unhealthy environment, problems paying medical bills, lack of health insurance, lacking a primary care physician, and problems with a current or former job, among other variables.
Of the 1809 caregivers recruited, 67.5% spoke English and the majority (86.7%) were women with an average age of 33 years. Caregivers were randomized to the active control group (937 [51.8%]) and the navigator intervention group (872 [48.2%]).
Out of 1300 families, 840 were recruited from urgent care facilities while most children (59.9%) were between ages 0 and 5. The majority of children (55.6%) were of Hispanic ethnicity.
Health care utilization was determined based on the number and date of emergency department (ED) visits and hospitalizations obtained from electronic health record data.
Although researchers found no significant difference in risk of an ED visit between the 2 groups throughout the 12-month follow-up period, data revealed:
- The active control group had 55 hospitalizations, with a mean of 0.08 hospitalizations per child (SD 0.30; 95% CI, 0.06 to 0.11)
- The patient navigator group had 35 hospitalizations, averaging 0.05 hospitalizations per child (SD 0.30; 95% CI, 0.03 to 0.08)
- Significantly fewer children from the in-person navigation group (29 [4.6%]) were admitted to the hospital during the year following enrollment compared with children from the active control group (50 [7.5%]; risk difference, −3.0%; 95% CI, −5.6% to −0.4%; relative risk, 0.60; 95% CI, 0.39 to 0.94)
- Children enrolled in the navigator intervention group had a decreased risk of being hospitalized (hazard ratio 0.59; 95% CI, 0.38-0.94; P = .03), making them 69% less likely to be hospitalized than children in the active control group
Currently, the average cost of a nonbirth pediatric inpatient hospitalization is $13,400, according to researchers, and the integration of an in-person navigator could lead to cost savings. To better understand the benefits of investing in the navigation intervention, cost-effectiveness analyses should be conducted, the authors noted.
Based on the results,the researchers hypothesized “decreased social risks may help families prioritize healthy behaviors, such as nutritious food or physical activity, or decrease unhealthy exposures, such as mold.” However, the current study does not clarify how the intervention specifically operated. Future research on how addressing social needs contributed to changes in children’s health and healthcare utilization should also be conducted, they wrote.
“The services of a volunteer navigator, who worked with families longitudinally to help them connect with available social services, were associated with reduced risk of child hospitalization,” the authors concluded. “Social care programs in other pediatric settings could potentially result in large reductions in inpatient stays and associated cost savings.”
Reference:
Pantell MS, Hessler D, Long D, et al. Effects of in-person navigation to address family social needs on child health care utilization: A randomized clinical trial [published online June 1, 2020]. JAMA Netw Open. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.6445
Social Needs Resource Navigators Help Limit Children's Health Care Utilization
Research has established an association between social risk factors and child health outcomes, while professional medical organizations have endorsed screening for such factors in clinical settings. Providing an in-person patient navigator to address family social needs leads to a decrease in child health care utilization, according to a study published in JAMA Network Open.
Providing an in-person patient navigator to address family social needs can decrease child health care utilization, according to a study published in JAMA Network Open.
Previous research has established an association between social risk factors and child health outcomes, while professional medical organizations have endorsed screening for such factors in clinical settings.
Although uptake of screening has been inconsistent, the practice is more likely to occur in settings with high numbers of low-income patients. However, few studies have documented health effects of interventions designed to reduce identified social needs, according to researchers.
In a randomized clinical trial of 1300 families, investigators compared acute care utilization effects of a written resources handout with an in-person navigation service intervention to address social needs.
Between 2013 and 2015, adult caregivers of pediatric patients seen in primary and urgent care clinics of 2 safety-net hospitals in California were recruited to participate in the study. To address each family’s social needs, families were randomly assigned to an in-person navigator intervention (637 families [49%]) or an active control (663 families [51%]).
In the active control cohort, caregivers received written information about relevant local resources related to social needs, while the navigator intervention consisted of meeting with a patient navigator focused on helping resolve such social needs.
Specifically, “navigators contacted families every 2 weeks via telephone, email, or in person for up to 3 months or until either identified needs were met or caregivers declined ongoing assistance.” In the intervention group, navigators also “provided assistance connecting caregivers with clinic, government, or community resources targeted specifically to the social barriers that had been endorsed and prioritized by the caregiver.”
Social risk data were collected from each household using a questionnaire that asked about the following domains: food insecurity, problems paying utility bills, problems finding employment, housing instability, living in an unhealthy environment, problems paying medical bills, lack of health insurance, lacking a primary care physician, and problems with a current or former job, among other variables.
Of the 1809 caregivers recruited, 67.5% spoke English and the majority (86.7%) were women with an average age of 33 years. Caregivers were randomized to the active control group (937 [51.8%]) and the navigator intervention group (872 [48.2%]).
Out of 1300 families, 840 were recruited from urgent care facilities while most children (59.9%) were between ages 0 and 5. The majority of children (55.6%) were of Hispanic ethnicity.
Health care utilization was determined based on the number and date of emergency department (ED) visits and hospitalizations obtained from electronic health record data.
Although researchers found no significant difference in risk of an ED visit between the 2 groups throughout the 12-month follow-up period, data revealed:
Currently, the average cost of a nonbirth pediatric inpatient hospitalization is $13,400, according to researchers, and the integration of an in-person navigator could lead to cost savings. To better understand the benefits of investing in the navigation intervention, cost-effectiveness analyses should be conducted, the authors noted.
Based on the results,the researchers hypothesized “decreased social risks may help families prioritize healthy behaviors, such as nutritious food or physical activity, or decrease unhealthy exposures, such as mold.” However, the current study does not clarify how the intervention specifically operated. Future research on how addressing social needs contributed to changes in children’s health and healthcare utilization should also be conducted, they wrote.
“The services of a volunteer navigator, who worked with families longitudinally to help them connect with available social services, were associated with reduced risk of child hospitalization,” the authors concluded. “Social care programs in other pediatric settings could potentially result in large reductions in inpatient stays and associated cost savings.”
Reference:
Pantell MS, Hessler D, Long D, et al. Effects of in-person navigation to address family social needs on child health care utilization: A randomized clinical trial [published online June 1, 2020]. JAMA Netw Open. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.6445
Commonwealth Fund Report Details Pervasive Racial and Ethnic Disparities in US Health Care, Outcomes
April 18th 2024Using 25 health system performance indicators, the Commonwealth Fund 2024 State Health Disparities Report evaluated racial and ethnic disparities in health care and health outcomes both within and across US states and highlighted the urgent need for equitable health care policies and practices in the US.
Read More
Health Equity Conversations: Managing Underserved Communities and Value-Based Payment
May 23rd 2023On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we feature several leaders in diversity, equity, and inclusion advancing health equity in their respective organization’s policy and practice initiatives.
Listen
Top 5 Most-Read Articles From the Center of Health Equity and Access 2023
December 25th 2023The top articles of 2023 addressed key issues such as representation gaps in aRCC research, concerns about the 340B program's impact on asthma disparities, slow adoption of equity innovations, potential biases in type 2 diabetes risk models, and addressing disparities in psoriasis treatment based on race and culture.
Read More
Health Equity Conversations: Barriers to Equitable Care
April 25th 2023On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we feature several leaders in diversity, equity, and inclusion advancing health equity in their respective organization’s policy and practice initiatives.
Listen
Understanding the Social Risk Factor Adjustment’s Effect on Star Ratings
December 20th 2023This article examines how CMS’ adjustment for social risk factors affects the Medicare Advantage Star Ratings and the type of contracts affected by the adjustment.
Read More
Review Showcases Key Postdischarge Strategies for Substance Use Treatment Success
December 14th 2023A collection of studies was used to analyze the strongest strategies in acute-care settings for patients with substance use disorders.
Read More
Commonwealth Fund Report Details Pervasive Racial and Ethnic Disparities in US Health Care, Outcomes
April 18th 2024Using 25 health system performance indicators, the Commonwealth Fund 2024 State Health Disparities Report evaluated racial and ethnic disparities in health care and health outcomes both within and across US states and highlighted the urgent need for equitable health care policies and practices in the US.
Read More
Health Equity Conversations: Managing Underserved Communities and Value-Based Payment
May 23rd 2023On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we feature several leaders in diversity, equity, and inclusion advancing health equity in their respective organization’s policy and practice initiatives.
Listen
Top 5 Most-Read Articles From the Center of Health Equity and Access 2023
December 25th 2023The top articles of 2023 addressed key issues such as representation gaps in aRCC research, concerns about the 340B program's impact on asthma disparities, slow adoption of equity innovations, potential biases in type 2 diabetes risk models, and addressing disparities in psoriasis treatment based on race and culture.
Read More
Health Equity Conversations: Barriers to Equitable Care
April 25th 2023On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we feature several leaders in diversity, equity, and inclusion advancing health equity in their respective organization’s policy and practice initiatives.
Listen
Understanding the Social Risk Factor Adjustment’s Effect on Star Ratings
December 20th 2023This article examines how CMS’ adjustment for social risk factors affects the Medicare Advantage Star Ratings and the type of contracts affected by the adjustment.
Read More
Review Showcases Key Postdischarge Strategies for Substance Use Treatment Success
December 14th 2023A collection of studies was used to analyze the strongest strategies in acute-care settings for patients with substance use disorders.
Read More