When employers only offer high-deductible health plans, they reduce costs by reducing utilization. However, consumers reduce their use of essential as well as nonessential services, which is sub-optimal for their long-term health, explained Niteesh Choudhry, MD, PhD, associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School.
When employers only offer high-deductible health plans, they reduce costs by reducing utilization. However, consumers reduce their use of essential as well as nonessential services, which is sub-optimal for their long-term health, explained Niteesh Choudhry, MD, PhD, associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School.
Transcript (modified)
Some employers are making the move to only offer high-deductible health plans. What would be the impact of that?
We know a bunch of things about high-deductible health plans right now, and most of the literature comes from those high full-replacement kinds of plans where employers one day say “Okay, everybody’s being shifted to a higher-deductible product.”
So the first thing that we know is that they definitely reduce spending and so they do what they’re intended to do. They’re designed to save the employer’s money—the best estimates that we have is at about $500 per member per year is what they end up doing, so that’s successful. They do that by reducing utilization more than anything else, so they reduce the use of all kinds of services: medications, radiology, emergency rooms, office visits, and so on.
The positive side, again the reduction in cost, is really a facet of reduction in utilization. On the negative side, what we know is that the reduction in utilization is both for services that we would call “low value,” or less essential or nonessential, as well as for services that appear to be essential. And so people end up making choices that are sub-optimal for at least their long-term health, or perhaps even their short-term pain or suffering, because of the nature of the benefit design.
The benefit design, as they’re intended to do, means that more people are put at risk for short-term costs and financial burden, and the literature we have says that people actually struggle a little bit more when they’re on these plans as compared to traditional plans.
Increasing Lp(a) Awareness for Better Cardiovascular Health: Dr Mary McGowan
March 24th 2024For Lp(a) Awareness Day, Mary McGowan, MD, FNLA, chief medical officer of the Family Heart Foundation, highlights how most people with elevated Lp(a) are completely unaware that they have this increased risk and calls for increased testing.
Read More
Exploring Medicare Advantage Prior Authorization Variations
March 26th 2024On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we're talking with the authors of a study published in the March 2024 issue of The American Journal of Managed Care® about their findings on variations in prior authorization use across Medicare Advantage plans.
Listen
Kathy Oubre on Strategies to Mitigate Challenges When Adopting New Payment Models
February 23rd 2024While adopting new payment models can come with challenges, there are strategies that can help oncology practices optimize their approaches, said Kathy Oubre, MS, CEO of Pontchartrain Cancer Center.
Read More
Getting to Know Dr Shauna Downs, Public Health Nutritionist
February 23rd 2024Shauna Downs, PhD, MS, is an associate professor in the Department of Health Behavior, Society, and Policy at the Rutgers School of Public Health. A former figure skater, her research now focuses on interventions to promote healthy and sustainable food choices and exploring how our changing climate, food systems, diet, and nutrition are inextricably linked.
Read More