Pharmacy benefit manager executives told members of the Senate Finance Committee that rebates are not the cause of high drug prices, and that more must be done to end evergreening and pay-for-delay tactics. Senators were skeptical.
Are pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) the reason for higher drug prices, or do they bring value and negotiate better deals? Those 2 questions were before the Senate Finance Committee Tuesday, which held its third hearing of the year related to pharmaceutical drug prices.
The hearings are a bipartisan effort between Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, who questioned whether PBMs prefer high-cost drugs that come with big rebates over cheaper drugs, and also whether consolidation in the industry, which is happening as drug makers buy PBMs, is contributing to the problem.
Ranking Member Ron Wyden, D-Oregon, as well as several other senators, questioned how PBMs bring value to consumers and taxpayers.
“Whether pharmacy benefit managers bring any real value to taxpayers is a mystery,” Wyden said.
Most drugs do not have rebates, said Steve Miller, MD, executive vice president and chief clinical officer of Cigna, which owns Express Scripts. Ninety percent of the prescriptions they fill are generics, he said.
Rebates are used in specific situations, such as branded drugs with competition.
Besides Cigna, the other companies that sent executives were CVS Health, which owns Caremark; UnitedHealth, which owns OptumRx; Prime Theraputics, and Humana.
Drugmakers blame rebates for the problem of rising drug prices, as has HHS Secretary Alex Azar, who is proposing to end rebates in Medicare Part D in 2020.
The Washington Post reported Tuesday that the administration may delay the end of rebates until after the 2020 election, so as not to cause backlash against Donald Trump.
But PBMs blame drugmakers, with John M. Prince, chief executive officer of OptumRx, citing patent evergreening and pay-to-delay tactics along with annual price increases. He also cited the cost of specialty drugs,
“When we have competition, we can bring down drug prices,” said Derica Rice, executive vice president and president, CVS Health and CVS Caremark.
The PBMs said they only offer rebates on about 8% of the prescriptions. They also said that they pass along most of those discounts to payers.
Part of the discussion turned to “spread pricing,” which is the difference between what a plan sponsor is billed and what a participating pharmacy is reimbursed. In some cases, whether or not a contract contains rebates or spread pricing is up to the client and how they choose to pay, the executives told senators.
Drug company executives said they want to offer more of those rebates directly to patients when they buy the drugs, an upfront approach to the discounts favored by President Donald Trump’s administration.
The executives said they were open to more transparency, such as having advisory bodies to Congress examine their way of doing business, but only so long as confidential information is kept from the public, they said.
In one of the more heated moments of the day, Sen. Ben Cardin, D-Maryland, took the PBM executives to task by bringing up shortages of common medicines and demanded to know what they were doing to solve the problem. He was mostly met with silence.
Oncology Onward: A Conversation With Thyme Care CEO and Cofounder Robin Shah
October 2nd 2023Robin Shah, CEO of Thyme Care, which he founded in 2020 with Bobby Green, MD, president and chief medical officer, joins hosts Emeline Aviki, MD, MBA, and Stephen Schleicher, MD, MBA, to discuss his evolution as an entrepreneur in oncology care innovation and his goal of positively changing how patients experience the cancer system.
Listen
HMO and EPO Insurance Plans More Likely to Promote Use of Biosimilars
November 21st 2023Health plan type highly influences the likelihood of biosimilar uptake, with low-flexibility insurance plans more likely to have patients who either switched to a biosimilar or were initiated on a biosimilar.
Read More
Oncology Onward: A Conversation With Dr Debra Patt of Texas Oncology
August 1st 2023Debra Patt, MD, PhD, MBA, joins hosts Emeline Aviki, MD, MBA, and Stephen Schleicher, MD, MBA, for episode 2 of our newest podcast, "Oncology Onward: Conversations With Innovators and Changemakers in Cancer Care."
Listen
Therapists’ Perspectives on Access to Telemental Health Among Medicaid-Enrolled Youth
November 10th 2023This qualitative study elucidates therapists’ perspectives on barriers to and facilitators of access to telemental health among Medicaid-enrolled youth served by a large safety-net organization.
Read More