Contrary to popular opinion, hospitals that receive lower reimbursements from public programs often cut fees to private payers to adjust to the new normal. Medicaid expansion, in particular, has had a net positive effect because hospitals are faced with less uncompensated care.
Austin Frakt, PhD, a health economist with the Department of Veterans’ Affairs, has offered a commentary to dispel a widely held belief: that hospitals charge commercial insurers higher prices to make up for what they lose with Medicare and Medicaid patients. Frakt is a member of the editorial board of The American Journal of Managed Care®.
His essay appears on JAMA Forum, and comes as Republican members of Congress appear poised to use the budget resolution process to unravel the Affordable Care Act (ACA), possibly in the first weeks of President-elect Donald J. Trump’s administration. At this point, however, no viable replacement for the ACA is in sight, and Democrats have vowed to push back.
In this atmosphere, Frakt addresses the gulf between what the public believes and what the evidence shows. In part, he writes, it’s due to statements from payers themselves: he quotes the president of Blue Cross Blue Shield Vermont saying that payers must charge commercial customers higher rates to make up for the “shortfall created by government reimbursements.”
But Frakt asserts that “it’s been nearly 2 decades since any rigorous study has found evidence of substantial cost shifting.” In fact, he writes, the opposite is true—when Medicare and Medicaid cut payments, hospitals cut what they charge private insurers, which peg their reimbursements to the new normal. It makes sense that this happens, Frakt says, because hospitals want to be included in as many networks as possible.
Cost shifting only works if a hospital enjoys enough market power that it knows payers must include it in networks, even if its costs are not aligned with the public programs. He discusses recent work by Kathryn Wagner, PhD, MA, of Marquette on the effects of Medicaid expansion on hospital charges to private payers.
Frakt makes an important distinction. “Even if hospitals do not cost shift, they still cross subsidize. The additional revenue hospitals receive from higher payments from private insurers enable the provision of less profitable services. But this isn’t cost-shifting unless there is a causal, dynamic connection in which private prices rise because of public revenue shortfalls.”
Fears of cost shifting from Medicaid expansion are unfounded, in part because the trend has allowed hospitals to rely less on funds for uncompensated care. Multiple reports that compare the fortunes of safety net hospitals in expansion vs non-expansion states show that some urban hospitals are running in the black for the first time in decades, while many rural states, especially in the Deep South, have seen small hospitals close—uncompensated care funds have dwindled and patients who might have been eligible for Medicaid expansion show up at their doors without any coverage.
Prices for care at hospital trauma centers vary across hospitals; drug shortages reached a record high during the first quarter of 2024; although 3 of the biggest makers of asthma inhalers pledged to cap out-of-pocket costs for some US patients at $35, these do not apply to daily inhalers used by the youngest kids with asthma.
Read More
Navigating Health Policy in an Election Year: Insights From Dr Dennis Scanlon
April 2nd 2024On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we're talking with Dennis Scanlon, PhD, the editor in chief of The American Journal of Accountable Care®, about prior authorization, price transparency, the impact of health policy on the upcoming election, and more.
Listen
The Biden administration recently launched the Global Health Security Strategy, a new effort to combat the spread of infectious diseases; lawmakers zeroed in on the risks of massive consolidation in health care during the first congressional hearing on the Change Healthcare hack; the FDA recently announced the recall of a pair of heart devices linked to numerous deaths and injuries.
Read More
Exploring Medicare Advantage Prior Authorization Variations
March 26th 2024On this episode of Managed Care Cast, we're talking with the authors of a study published in the March 2024 issue of The American Journal of Managed Care® about their findings on variations in prior authorization use across Medicare Advantage plans.
Listen