After Senate Bill Falters, a Fresh Round of Single Payer Chatter
In the days since Senator John McCain (R-Arizona) turned down his thumb and became the third Republican to vote against the “skinny repealâ€
In the days since Senator John McCain (R-Arizona) turned down his thumb and became the third Republican to vote against the “
“Single payer” calls for one public or quasi-public agency to be in charge of paying for healthcare, even though delivery is performed by private entities. It’s how Medicare, and especially Medicare Advantage, functions today—the federal government pays the costs, but insurers manage contracts and beneficiaries can pick a plan.
In his presidential bid, Senator Bernie Sanders (I-Vermont) called it “Medicare for all.” He is
While coverage touting the merits of a single-payer system is a staple for progressive outlets like
Single payer has support from a physicians’ group,
Given the makeup of Congress—not to mention President Donald Trump's presence—a conversion to a pure single-payer system seems highly unlikely. But hybrid plans that combine free-market elements with single-payer solutions for high-cost populations aren’t so far off the table.
That’s what a pair of writers in
“The best way forward is to resort to the free market first, and then, if affordable insurance (especially for pre-existing conditions) is not obtainable, direct government subsidy would be permissible,” wrote Joshua Ronen, of NYU Stern School of Business, and Kenneth A. Sagat, a lawyer at Sagat Burton LLP.
The hybrid option deals with the toughest cases, while a pure single-payer system would be unsustainably expensive, some say. Billionaire Mark Cuban is in this camp, as he explained in a
Exactly why single payer won't work. You will get lower cost health care but get taxed into oblivion
— Mark Cuban (@mcuban)
Newsletter
Stay ahead of policy, cost, and value—subscribe to AJMC for expert insights at the intersection of clinical care and health economics.
Related Articles
- Eating Behaviors May Predict GLP-1 Therapy Success in Type 2 Diabetes
September 18th 2025
- Modest Reductions in PrEP Coverage Result in Avoidable HIV Infections
September 17th 2025